If
you had a chance to interview him, what would you ask the man who many
regard as the best coach in the history of European football, and
perhaps sports as a whole? I can imagine many fans have pondered that
question, but last year it took on greater relevance for me.
That's
because in what turned out to be Sir Alex Ferguson's last eighteen
months in charge at Manchester United, my former student Tom Dye and I
had a unique opportunity to study the legendary coach's leadership
approach. We were able to conduct lengthy interviews with the man
himself, we followed him around as he went about his daily activities on
United's training ground, we saw him in action at the stadium, we
interviewed several players, and we spoke with many people around him,
from the club's kit manager to the chief executive officer. Not your
average academic research project, in other words.
We captured some of our initial findings in a case study, released last fall (see here and here and here for some media coverage). Today, the Harvard Business Review
published a second result of the study: an article, titled "Ferguson's
Formula" and co-authored with Sir Alex, in which he provides his
perspective on eight critical leadership lessons, offering unique
insights into what it takes to build and manage teams.
I obviously can't reproduce the full article here -- it is available through the Harvard Business Review 's website
-- but I thought it might be helpful to list the lessons, and for each
lesson select one quote that I found especially insightful. Here we go:
Lesson 1. Start with the Foundation
"When
you give young people a chance, you not only create a longer life span
for the team, you also create loyalty. They will always remember that
you were the manager who gave them their first opportunity."
Lesson 2. Dare to Rebuild Your Team
"The
hardest thing is to let go of a player who has been a great guy -- but
all the evidence is on the field. If you see the change, the
deterioration, you have to ask yourself what things are going to be like
two years ahead."
Lesson 3. Set High Standards -- and Hold Everyone To Them
"I
constantly told my squad that working hard all your life is a talent.
But I expected even more from the star players. I expected them to work
even harder."
Lesson 4. Never, Ever Cede Control
"There
are occasions when you have to ask yourself whether certain players are
affecting the dressing-room atmosphere, the performance of the team,
and your control of the players and the staff. If they are, you have to
cut the cord."
Lesson 5. Match the Message to the Moment
"For
a player -- for any human being -- there is nothing better than hearing
'Well done.' Those are the two best words ever invented."
Lesson 6. Prepare to Win
"I
am a gambler—a risk taker—and you can see that in how we played in the
late stages of matches. ... If we were still down—say, 1–2—with 15
minutes to go, I was ready to take more risks. I was perfectly happy to
lose 1–3 if it meant we’d given ourselves a good chance to draw or to
win. So in those last 15 minutes, we’d go for it."
Lesson 7. Rely on the Power of Observation
"I
came to see observation as a critical part of my management skills. The
ability to see things is key -- or, more specifically, the ability to
see things you don't expect to see."
Lesson 8. Never Stop Adapting
"Most people with my kind of track record don't look to change. But I always felt I couldn't afford not to change."
Anita Elberse is the Lincoln Filene Professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School. She is the author of a book, Blockbusters: Hit-making, Risk-taking, and the Big Business of Entertainment, (in stores next month but available to pre-order now), and faculty chair of an HBS Executive Education program, “The Business of Entertainment, Media, and Sports.”
In
the world of technology, companies are increasingly moving beyond
growing organically and using acquisitions to enlarge their operations.
Some have also made a strategic decision to acquire R&D rather than
try to grow innovation in house.
Take for example Apple’s acquisition this summer of Toronto-based Locationary,
the venture-backed startup that specializes in location data.
According to a number of market experts, this deal allows Apple – which
has its own R&D division – to immediately augment its mapping
service so that users can access up-to-date information on local
businesses.
Whether the acquirer is Apple, Google or Blackberry, the objective in these acquisitions must be carefully defined. That’s the view of John Banks, who teaches MBA students about M&A at Waterloo, Ontario’s Wilfrid Laurier University. “Regardless
of how attractive the deal price or fortuitous the opportunity, it is
essential that the impact the acquisition is intended to have on the
company’s strategic direction be both understood and realistic for the
transaction to be truly successful,” Banks says.
Enterprises that use M&A to supplement their R&D can approach
acquisitions in a passive or active way. Those doing a formal search
process tend to have access to strong corporate finance skills and are
able to apply rigorous valuations and criteria for potential deals.
Banks agrees with the value of using specialized expertise: “The
assessment needs to be especially meticulous since research shows that
this particular aspect of M&A is often characterized by incomplete
if not irrational thinking.”
A smaller company is often attractive as an acquisition target
because it can have the flexibility of a speed boat that manoeuvers
rapidly around larger ships. “There is the ability for a small company
to be nimble and to not be hampered by bureaucracy. They can do R&D
at a quicker pace and without legacy products,” says Amar Varma, founder of Xtreme Labs, a Toronto-based provider of mobile solutions to businesses. (Varma coached BumpTop prior to its acquisition by Google in 2010.)
The issue for a larger company that chooses to use M&A to develop
an innovative product pipeline is the risk of missing the window of
opportunity to buy. If the targets are very attractive, they will be
acquired. Google bought YouTube and capitalized on gaining a unique business while it was still available in the market.
A common impetus to enter acquisition mode is when the larger company
is looking to grow by boosting a product or service offering. Once the
target has been identified, it’s all about timing.
Says Varma: “Startups are continually looking for cash. The ability
for a startup to obtain cash through customers or investors can
significantly impact the upward trajectory of the deal price. This means
the acquirer must purchase a startup at the optimal time – before there
is too much competition to buy. Often, there is no demand until there
is demand.”
When a company uses acquisitions to supplement its R&D, the
corporate finance process needs to be highly streamlined and focused on
its mission. “In order for an acquisition to go well, there needs to be
strategic alignment for the bigger vision of the deal, an appropriate
integration plan that minimizes day-to-day disruptions, and
consideration for the cultural fit of both companies,” says Haroon Mirza, entrepreneur in residence at OMERS Ventures and co-founder of CognoVision, which was acquired by Intel in 2010.
The period immediately after the acquisition can be challenging,
particularly if the small enterprise bought for R&D development has a
superior product, as this can cause resentment by the acquirer’s team
of employees. The need for cultural fit suddenly becomes startlingly
clear. The on-boarding entrepreneurs will need a top executive at the
acquiring business to champion the buy.
“It becomes important to keep employees of the acquiree informed
about what the acquisition means for them – this can be a confusing time
for employees who may feel their jobs are at risk and could consider
leaving if they’re not well-informed,” Mirza explains.
Mirza was satisfied with his and his co-founders’ decision to have
CognoVision acquired by Intel. “I do agree that an M&A can be a
viable alternative to organic growth. For the acquirer, benefits include
immediate access to intellectual property, business and technical
domain expertise in terms of talent, and also our customers.
“For the acquired company, benefits include gaining access to
significantly more resources for R&D, sales and marketing which can
accelerate business growth by means of improved sales reach, cost
optimization, and increased revenues.”
Jacoline Loewen is a director at Crosbie & Co. Inc.,
a provider of advice to small and medium-sized businesses. She is also
the author of “Money Magnet: How to Attract Investors to Your Business.”
Whether we're looking at business or politics, sports or
entertainment, it's clear we live in an era of self-celebration. Fame is
equated with success, and being self-referential has become the norm.
As a result we are encouraged to pump ourselves full of alarming
self-confidence. Bluster and the alpha instinct, contends Tomas
Chamorro-Premuzic, professor of business psychology, often get mistaken
for ability and effectiveness (at least for a while). It may well be why
so many (incompetent) men rise ahead of women to leadership positions,
as Chamorro-Premuzic argued in a recent HBR post.
Yes, we have scores of books, articles, and studies that warn us of
the perils of hubris. The word comes from the Greek and means extreme
pride and arrogance, generally indicating a loss of connection to
reality brought about when those in power vastly overestimate their
capabilities. And yes, many of us have also seen evidence that its
opposite, humility, inspires loyalty, helps to build and sustain
cohesive, productive team work, and decreases staff turnover. Jim
Collins had a lot to say about CEOs he saw demonstrating modesty and
leading quietly, not charismatically, in his 2001 bestseller Good to Great.
Yet the attribute of humility seems to be neglected in leadership
development programs. And to the extent it is considered by managers
rising through the ranks, it is often misunderstood. How can we change
this?
First, let's get a few things straight. Humility is not hospitality,
courtesy, or a kind and friendly demeanor. Humility has nothing to do
with being meek, weak, or indecisive. Perhaps more surprising, it does
not entail shunning publicity. Organizations need people who get
marketing, including self-marketing, to flourish and prosper.
Hubris, meanwhile, is not a fair label to apply to any person who
thinks differently and has the courage to assert or act on their
convictions. Studies show,
however, that serious problems emerge when robust individualism
commingles with narcissism — another term for which we can thank the
Greeks (whose demigod Narcissus fell in love with his own reflection).
Narcissism combines an exaggerated sense of one's own abilities and
achievements with a constant need for attention, affirmation, and
praise. While the label tends to be applied loosely to anyone behaving
in a self-absorbed way, psychologists know narcissism to be a formal
personality disorder for some, and a real impediment to their forming
healthy relationships. The narcissist lacks self-awareness and empathy
and is often hypersensitive to criticism or perceived insults. He or she
frequently exaggerates contributions and claims to be "expert" at many
different things. If you are part of an organization with a leader
exhibiting such characteristics, you have a problem. (Executive search
firms and hiring committees beware.)
But beyond refusing to hire or promote such extreme cases, can and
should organizations try to cultivate more humility in their leadership
ranks? How would that goal take shape in the context of a formal
leadership development program? As a starting point, we would suggest a
curriculum designed around six basic principles. If you're a developing
leader, you should be taught to:
Know what you don't know.
Resist "master of the universe" impulses. You may yourself excel in an
area, but as a leader you are, by definition, a generalist. Rely on
those who have relevant qualification and expertise. Know when to defer
and delegate.
Resist falling for your own publicity.
We all do it: whether we're writing a press release or a self-appraisal,
we put the best spin on our success — and then conveniently forget that
the reality wasn't as flawless. Drinking in the glory of a triumph can
be energizing. Too big a drink is intoxicating. It blurs vision and
impairs judgment.
Never underestimate the competition.
You may be brilliant, ambitious, and audacious. But the world is filled
with other hard-working, high-IQ, and creative professionals. Don't kid
yourself that they and their innovations aren't a serious threat.
Embrace and promote a spirit of service.
Employees quickly figure out which leaders are dedicated to helping them
succeed, and which are scrambling for personal success at their
expense. Customers do, too.
Listen, even (no, especially) to the weird ideas.
Only when you are not convinced that your idea is or will be better than
someone else's do you really open your ears to what they are saying.
But there is ample evidence that you should: the most imaginative and
valuable ideas tend to come from left field, from some associate who seems a little offbeat, and may not hold an exalted position in the organization.
Be passionately curious.
Constantly welcome and seek out new knowledge, and insist on curiosity from those around you. Research has found linkages between
curiosity and many positive leadership attributes (including emotional
and social intelligence). Take it from Einstein. "I have no special
talent," he claimed. "I am only passionately curious."
We can't imagine that an individual exposed to the six principles
above and encouraged to take them to heart could become anything but a
better leader.
But meanwhile, assuming your organization isn't already helping its
leaders develop such habits of mind, let us leave you with two humble,
and humbling, suggestions. First: subject yourself to a 360 review.
Anonymous feedback from the people who surround you may constitute a
mirror you won't love gazing into, but as Ann Landers wrote: "Don't
accept your dog's admiration as conclusive evidence that you are
wonderful." 360 feedback pays off in two ways. It shows you how your
self-perception deviates from others' perception of your leadership.
(And in leadership, perception is reality.) And it gives you a valuable
practice in receiving feedback and turning criticism into a plan for
growth and development.
Second, get a coach. We all have blind spots, and there's certainly no shame in getting help with them. Fast Company reports
that 43% of CEOs and 71% of Senior Executives say they've worked with a
coach. And 92% of leaders being coached say they plan to use a coach
again.
Resolve to work on your own humility and you will begin to notice and
appreciate its power all around you. In a recent meeting we convened in
Los Angeles, the accomplished Chairman and CEO of a major Hollywood
studio shared the benefit of his experience with 20 young professionals
and students. What did this leader emphasize with the group? He spoke of
his own failures, weaknesses, and blind spots, and how they had spurred
his learning and success. The fact that he spoke about himself in this
way deeply impressed the group. He projected convincing self-confidence,
authenticity, and wisdom.
He was a convincing example of the kind of leader our organizations
should be trying harder to develop — the kind that knows it's better to
develop a taste for humility now than be forced to eat humble pie later.
Recent CEB research
shows that work has become much more interdependent — employees
increasingly need to tap a broader array of internal and external
colleagues and partners to be successful in their jobs. The emergence of
this new work environment
has significant implications for how IT should enable business growth
and, more specifically, for the kinds of investments IT should be making
to support employees.
Unfortunately, when it comes to IT's ability to allocate investments
in response to the new work environment, traditional governance
processes prove grossly outdated. Some of the key challenges:
- Companies don't identify the very best ideas for investment
because most capital allocation processes start with business partners'
existing ideas about projects to fund. As we've noted in our previous blog, senior business partners might not be that knowledgeable about what actually drives productivity on the front lines.
- Companies allocate capital to the wrong investments because our
traditional emphasis on ROI-based business cases undermines IT's ability
to invest in high-return-but-hard-to-measure areas like improving
knowledge worker productivity.
- Companies tend to spread their capital allocation bets too thinly
across business groups or functions, often for political reasons. This
practice helps 'keep the peace' but means that often the most
transformational opportunities get short-changed.
Across our year of research into this problem, we have identified a
select group of companies that are rethinking their governance and
investment processes to circumvent the problems outlined above.
Expand First, Filter Second
Most CIOs will tell you that they have no shortage of ideas to invest in
— the hard part is whittling down to the right ones. Push that a bit
further and what most CIOs say is that those ideas are in the form of
project requests from business partners. The problem is that these
"bottom-up" project requests often miss the big picture as too many are
incremental or uninspiring. Yes, while most of these requests are vetted
for alignment with corporate strategy, what's often missing is how
these requests fit within a broader context of how the business overall
generates value. Furthermore, this lack of context prevents
organizations from identifying other investment ideas that have high
potential but haven't bubbled up organically through project requests.
To address this challenge, a global transportation company we spoke
with is using a strategic lens to expand the list of project ideas to
find the ones with the highest potential corporate value, before
filtering them. They start with a map of the company's critical business
capabilities — those concrete business activities that are vital to
meeting a strategic goal (e.g. rapid new product roll-out). Then, they
look at the health of the information available to business leaders who
manage those capabilities. They find this leads them into all sorts of
overlooked opportunities and provides them with a good proxy for where
IT investment can have significant business impact, which can better
inform prioritization decisions.
Prioritize Capabilities, not Projects
The currency of most IT project prioritization meetings is the ROI-based
business case. As mentioned above, this measure works very well for
comparing projects that deliver hard benefits, but undermine the ability
to invest in critical capabilities that have a long-term payoff horizon
or highly innovative capabilities where the payoff is uncertain.
A global high-tech equipment provider is taking a different approach.
Similar to the transportation company mentioned earlier, they start with
a top down view of critical business capabilities and pillars required
to support long-term business strategy. Then, using customer preference
measurement methodologies like conjoint analysis, they survey senior
business leaders to determine the relative criticality of each of these
pillars. Based on this — and before any projects are even discussed —
they are able to map out the relative level of IT investment each
capability should receive. So, if the business leadership agrees that
capability A is twice as important to realizing their goals as
capability B, capability A is targeted for twice as much investment.
Projects can then be assessed on contribution to the needs of that
pillar, rather than purely on financial metrics like ROI.
CIOs are being asked to arm employees with the capabilities required
for success in a new, much more integrated and interdependent work
environment. But to do that requires more than capital: it requires a
different approach to making decisions and, specifically, rethinking
traditional IT project-centric approaches to identifying and funding
capital investment opportunities.
At its essence, strategy is a guide to behavior. And, when
communicating your strategic intent, the most important goal is
conveying your unique aspects and advantages with specific and engaging
words.
This is hard. But, if you’re not being challenged at coming up with
an effective strategy statement, you’re not trying hard enough. Because
It is a real challenge to translate strategy into execution, this is something we must continually work at, that is, communicating strategy. Research has found that only %14 of employees understand their company’s strategy and direction.
The strategy might be flawed, but even if it’s flawed communication
will not fix the problem. That is why you have to be clear and specific.
For example, one of the most clear specific strategy statements I’ve
ever heard is from Southwest Airlines (not surprise here huh?): To be
the low-cost airline.
Everything flows from that statement. It helps clarify decision
making at every level of the organization to the point where there is no
doubt in anyone’s mind of what they have to do. To get to that point,
Southwest Airlines also had to come up with a very clear and specific
strategy.
With that said, before writing an effective strategy statement, we must get the strategy right.
Here are 6 key attributes of an effective strategy, from the book The Strategist: Be the Leader your business needs:
The 6 Hallmarks of Great Strategies
- Anchored by a clear and compelling purpose. It is
said that “if you don’t know where you’re going, there isn’t a road that
can get you there.” Organizations should exist for a reason. What’s
yours?
- Add real value. Organizations that have a
difference that matters add value. If any of them were to go away, they
would be missed. Would yours?
- Clear choices. Excellence comes
from well-defined effort. Attempting to do too many things makes it
difficult to do any of them well. What has your business decided to do?
To not do?
- Tailored system of value creation. The first step
in great execution is translating an idea into a system of action, where
efforts are aligned and mutually reinforcing. Does this describe your
business? In most companies, the true answer is no.
- Meaningful metrics. Global outcome measures like
ROI indicate whether a strategy is working, but key performance drivers,
tailored to your own strategy, are a better indication. They break big
aspirations into specific, measurable goals, and guide behavior toward
what matters.
- Passion. It’s a soft concept, but it’s at the heart
of every great strategy. Even in the most mundane industries, companies
that stand out care deeply about what they do.
It's not a very easy thing to do--but it's the most powerful leadership tool at your disposal.
Some years ago, a friend and I were waiting at a bus stop. The bus
driver pulled up and stepped out of the bus to take a break. It was
winter, so he left the door open so that people could get on--trusting
that we would all pay our fares, which we all did.
After a few moments, he got back on and pulled away. "Excuse me,"
said one of the passengers, "Is this the day the fare goes up by ten
cents?"
"Yes it is," he said. And so every passenger on that bus, including
my boyfriend and me, got up to put an extra dime into the box.
The Power of Trust
I've seen the same sort of thing again and again. Few things are as
powerful as giving people your trust. It's a vitally important lesson
for anyone running a business because it's so easy to get this wrong. If
you trust people who work for you and they rip you off, or share inside
information, or otherwise deceive you, you'll feel like a fool. People
will call you naive. Most of us desperately want to avoid having that
happen, so we try to outsmart anyone who might try to "get over" on us.
That may seem wise, but it doesn't lead anywhere good. Another friend
of mine had a business selling computer parts and shipping them all
over the country. He employed a small team of customer service people
who answered phones, kept track of orders, and handled returns as
necessary. Although there were only five employees, he instituted a
sign-in, sign-out policy to keep track of them. When he learned that
some were spending some signed-in time making personal calls or eating
meals in the break room, he was furious, and began watching them
closely. Every time I saw my friend for dinner, the conversation would
revolve around how lazy his employees were.
Though the company's revenues were impressive, my friend eventually
had enough. He fired everyone, sold the business, and went to work for a
large corporation instead. Trusting people can cost you, but not
trusting them can cost you even more.
Why It Could Be Your Secret Sauce
My new hero when it comes to trust is Bobby Harris, CEO of BlueGrace Logistics. Harris and the rest of his executive team temporarily switched seats
with the company's cubicle dwellers, and when Harris gave his IT
maintenance guy his own office, he resisted all temptation to lock up or
hide important files. It sent a powerful message, he says. "You're
treating a professional like a professional. If you give someone an
office with a door, you trust him. And if you don't trust someone to be
alone in your office, you shouldn't employ that person."
BlueGrace has a tradition of providing beer for employees on Friday
evenings. "People ask if I'm concerned about liability," Harris says.
"But these are adults and I trust them to be responsible." I can't
attest to whether all BlueGrace employees are trustworthy, but the
company's success is hard to argue with. Begun in 2009--hardly an
auspicious moment to launch a new venture--BlueGrace achieved $80
million in annual sales within four years. It started offering
franchises about two years ago, and has 26 franchises so far, with more
coming on all the time.
"People ask me what the secret sauce is that makes the company so
successful," Harris says. "Trust is the secret sauce. The biggest thing
you can do is trust people."
MINDA ZETLIN
is a business technology writer and speaker, co-author of "The Geek
Gap," and president of the American Society of Journalists and Authors.
Try
to dissect why a great team wins a championship and you’ll quickly see
it’s all about the moving parts. Can the offense use speed and timing to
score frequently? Can the defense make the necessary adjustments to get
the job done? Can every player on the team remember their own
responsibilities and execute their tasks when needed? It’s fascinating
to see how independent assignments can influence the collective success
or failure of the team.
This month, a lot of national attention was placed on a plaque inside
the football locker room at the University of Notre Dame that
insinuated an easy return trip to college football’s BCS National
Championship game. But I will tell you there’s another sign in the
Fighting Irish locker room worth examining.
There is a poster that instructs players specifically how to keep
their respective areas. It includes a detailed description of where the
cleats should be placed, how the knee and ankle braces should be hung,
and even where the practice jersey should drape within the locker. Each
player is required to consistently arrange his locker as diagramed on
the poster.
For me, the significance of this poster is an absolute of how great
teams and successful businesses are able to take the step from good to
great; they simply pay attention to the little details.
By establishing such a thorough locker room protocol, the Notre Dame
players have taken a few minor decisions off the board. The time wasted
trying to find equipment needed for success can now be used for bigger
tasks and making decisions that could prove pivotal in achieving
greatness.
By instilling such a simple yet detail-oriented procedure, Notre Dame
head coach Brian Kelly was able to make it easier for his players to do
what’s expected of them. He was able to unlock more time for his team
to focus on being better players. He was able to build a structure that
showcased unity, discipline and an attention to detail.
What if an assembly line at an automobile plant didn’t have a
well-devised procedure? What if the nuts & bolts worker wasn’t as
efficient at following protocol as the wheels and tires guy? The overall
product is still viewed as faulty, regardless of which moving part
actually failed during the assembly.
Every successful business has moving parts. The Great ones understand
that their final product relies heavily on the attention to detail at
the beginning stages. By creating a simplified procedure, great leaders
emphasize that the little things are just as important to the overall
success as the bigger items. Once that becomes part of the culture, it
makes working on the bigger tasks much more effective.
What routine do you follow consistently that adds value to your own
productivity? What little detail can you tackle today that could make
your bigger challenges run more smoothly?